Planes, trains and trucks point to US economic downturn

Truck on road

Martyn Goddard | Getty Images

If the transportation industry is any indicator — and it usually is — then the economy could be on the brink of a downturn.

When the economy is on the decline, the transportation sector is one of the first things to go. According to a report by the U.S. Bureau of Transportation Statistics, shifts in its index that tracks train, truck, boat and plane activity occur before changes in economic growth, leading the wider economy by about four months.

The index has taken a negative turn starting in late 2015 and into the summer of 2016, according to CNBC calculations. While true turning points are usually identified after the fact, the recent downward momentum could signal a similar movement in the economy as a whole.

The freight transportation services index combines monthly truck tonnage, air revenue from freight and mail, weekly rail carloads, rail ton-miles, tons moved by water and pipeline transportation into a single indicator. A similar passenger index measures passenger miles and trips by plane, train and public transportation. Both measures have been found to change ahead of the wider economy.

“A very large portion of freight volume consists of raw materials and other intermediate goods, which may be ordered in anticipation of growing activity in the manufacturing sector,” BTS analysts wrote in their last historical review of the data.

Conversely, as downstream demand begins to falter, freight shipments also decline. While passenger travel is a consumer service and may be expected to lag or change with the economy, personal and business travel also seem to respond to economic confidence and sometimes lead other indicators.

By combining multiple types of weighted transportation data in the two indexes, the TSI captures overall economic changes rather than simple shifts in market conditions between the various transportation providers (such as a change from using trains to using trucks, for example).

A look at the recent shift in each component suggests that intermodal rail traffic — goods that are moved by multiple modes of transportation — as well as air transportation of freight and mail, and pipeline transportation are influencing the freight index.

The BTS encourages analysts to use the TSI indexes they provide in economic models, but does not itself forecast the expected states of the economy, said Dave Smallen, a BTS spokesperson. Smallen did not comment on whether the bureau has in recent months seen the same downward pattern that CNBC’s analysis reveals.

“We agree that the TSI can be useful as an economic indicator,” said Smallen. “Our past research has shown that a peak in freight TSI has almost always been followed by either a recession or a growth slowdown.”

In its last look at the historical data in 2014, BTS found that the passenger TSI anticipated the four most recent recessions, but that it also pointed to one more cycle that did not correspond with a recession. The freight index aligned with nearly every turning point in growth cycles since 1981, but also experienced a cycle from 2004 to 2006 that didn’t line up with a downturn.

According to The Wall Street Journal‘s regular survey of more than 60 economists, the chance in August of a recession sometime in the next year was around 21 percent, compared with about 8 percent a year ago. Three-fourths of economists also said that the risks to their GDP growth forecasts in the next year are more to the downside than upside.

As for the stock market, airlines have been underperforming the S&P 500 so far this year by 30 percentage points. Railroad stocks have been outperforming by about 10 points. The sector overall has shown some signs of rebounding: as of Thursday morning, S&P 500 transportation stocks are up nearly 3 percent over the last month, while the S&P has been flat.

This entry was posted in Transportation, US Economy. Bookmark the permalink.

Leave a Reply