Diabetes: The $54 billion battleground
Many of the world’s biggest drugmakers will gather Friday in San Francisco for the American Diabetes Association’s annual meeting. They’ll present data on medicines that make up a market worth $54 billion globally.
And it’s growing fast, according to the IMS Institute for Healthcare Informatics—at about $4 billion to $5 billion a year for the last five years, said Michael Kleinrock, the institute’s research director.
Sanofi, the largest drugmaker in France, makes the insulin Lantus. It drew 5.72 billion euros (more than US$6 billion) in 2013 revenue. But its patent expires in 2015. So Sanofi has been working on a next-generation product known as U300, or Toujeo, to take its place.
Read More Orexigen shares hit by FDA delay in obesity drug
The market may be underestimating that drug’s potential, according to Jefferies analyst Jeff Holford.
“With low expectations, we feel that a greater appreciation for U300 as a viable follow-on product will develop during the ADA meeting itself,” Holford wrote in a June 11 research note. “We would expect a rigorous debate in the market regarding the clinical significance of the U300 data vs. Lantus, and how this compares against Novo Nordisk’s Tresiba.”
Meanwhile, Indianapolis-based Eli Lilly will have data on its biosimilar version of Lantus, Holford said. (“Biosimilar” is the phrase used to describe a generic form of a medicine; because biologic drugs have a more complicated manufacturing process, the industry has opted to use the term “biosimilar.”)
Read More Investors eye Achillion for next big pharma deal
Holford doesn’t have high expectations for Lilly’s drug at ADA.
“With market expectations firmly set that this product will be approved by the FDA (though launch timing is uncertain, due to ongoing patent litigation with Sanofi), the risk is firmly on the downside for Eli Lilly at the ADA congress,” he said in a May 27 note.
Lilly also will present data on its experimental medicine dulaglutide in a head-to-head trial against Novo Nordisk’s Victoza, which drew 11.6 billion Danish kroner (about US$2.1 billion) in 2013 sales for the Danish drugmaker. Results already released show Lilly’s drug worked about the same to reduce blood sugar levels, though patients lost more weight on Victoza. A key difference, though, is that Lilly’s drug is injected once a week, versus a daily shot for Victoza.
“Would you want to be putting a needle seven times a week in your arm?,” John Boris, an analyst with SunTrust, said in a telephone interview Wednesday.
He said the data show an advantage to Lilly’s dulaglutide, which he expects to draw $1.5 billion in annual sales, compared with the Street’s average $1.2 billion estimate, he wrote in a June 9 research note.
The key question going into the ADA meeting is what doctors think about the data, especially on weight loss, said Mark Schoenebaum, an analyst with ISI Group. He expects Lilly’s drug to still gain significant market share in its class of medicines, called GLP-1s, noting they make up a $3 billion market that could grow to $5 billion “in the out years.”
Read More Why there’s no end in sight for higher drug costs
“It’s quite possible that even a 33 percent penetration rate is possible here (implying $1.7 billion in peak sales) given it has, on the overall, a competitive profile vs. Victoza,” Schoenebaum wrote in a June 9 research note of Lilly’s dulaglutide.
Finally, Lilly also will have data on a combination of drugs called empagliflozin and Tradjenta in an increasingly competitive area. AstraZeneca is presenting data on a similar combination of drugs, and Holford said he expects both to reach the market in 2015.
Which brings us to: